« "The Flu: What You Should Know" TV Special | Main | Making the holidays healthier »

November 23, 2009

Comments

Thomas Donaghey

My one-year-old daughter's pediatric practice has adopted a practice of refusing all children their second H1N1 flu shot until all children in the practice have had their first. They told me this when they phoned to cancel my daughter's Dec. 14th appointment. I've since heard from many other parents that their doctors' offices have adopted the same policy. Some believe the policy is mandated by the CDC, others that it originates with the Mass. DPH; still others told me they've heard it's considered a matter of fairness. I keep finding one widely publicized pilot study that showed kids under 2 had only a 25% chance of developing immunity to H1N1 with one shot, but the second shot provided all the kids with immunity. I think this policy might make sense for seasonal flu virus (which often isn't prevalent before December), but given that H1N1 has been widespread in Massachusetts for weeks now, this seems more of a recipe to guarantee the maximum number of unprotected kids for the longest possible time. Certainly 75% of the under-twos who see my daughter's doctor can expect to remain unprotected until after New Year's.

I would appreciate any insight into this policy that you can provide. Am I missing something? Does the policy originate with a public health agency?

Susan Cholakis

My 25 year old daughter has all of the symptoms of H1N1 flu, particularly high fever and muscles aches and pains, as well as some cold symptoms and a bad sore throat. She went to see her doctor this morning, and was seen by her nurse practitioner, who diagnosed her with an "upper respiratory bacterial infection" and gave her an antibiotic and an inhaler. Her symptoms were so obviously flu, yet when she called the NP later this afternoon to ask how to treat it-especially the severe muscle pain, the NP brushed her off and insisted that it was the bacterial infection that"a lot of people have" and refused to consider a diagnosis of flu. My daughter believes that there is a conspiracy among the health providers across the state to avoid diagnosing people with flu so as not to panic the general population. I am beginning to think she is correct. There seems to be no H1N1 flu vaccine anywhere in the state for children in their teens and early 20's.

Keith E. Herzog

I am traveling to China on December 24, returning January 2. I have read in the news that China has widespread H1N1 flu and that 80% of all flu in China is supposedly of the H1N1 variety. I am a normally healthy male, 50 years old, father of 3 kids ages 9, 7, and 6. I have been able to get the kids their H1N1 vaccinations, but it would seem prudent for me to be vaccinated before going to a high-risk country like China, yet I can find no doctors sympathetic to my cause... they all stick to the stringent guidelines that seem to exclude me at present. Should I be vaccinated for H1N1 before traveling to China, or is the shark move here to risk importing the virus into the U.S. when I return?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.